Welcome back to Joel Reads Bible. The story of Cain and Abel is one of the most famous Bible stories, but just because itâs been retold for millennia, doesnât mean the story makes sense or, more specifically, the characters are well motivated.
Letâs take a look!
The Setup
Eve has a âmanâ and sheâs so happy. Yay, boys.
The firstborn is Cain, the second-born is Abel. Cain is a farmer, Abel is a shepherd.
You wouldnât think this is going to tip Godâs favour in any way, but prepare to be surprised!
Out of the clear blue sky, God requires sacrifices. There are no instructions, there was no discussion back in the garden about it. Itâs almost as if sacrifices are ubiquitous in the culture of the folks writing the story, so the necessity is assumed.
But maybe God popped down and walked with Adam in the cool of the evening again and told him that on top of the curses which would eventually half-fail, they also need to destroy something of value every so often. He mustâve, because weâll learn later, he apparently knows what is ârightâ.
Thereâs an odd detail here, Abel gives the firstborn of his flock. Why? We know from Exodus, God starts requiring firstborns because he passed over the Hebrews and killed all those other firstborns of Egypt (cruelly). Itâs told as if those kinds of sacrifices are beginning then and motivated by the story. This might just be an anachronism. Unless God has always just required first fruits and the âfirst that open the wombâ, but then the new command in Exodus 12 wouldnât really mean much.
The Mistake
Cain is doing his best, minding his own business, stabbing vegetables for God, but Abel, because of his vocation, is slicing throats and bleeding out sentient beings.
God loves blood!
God loves the smell of burning flesh, so naturally he loves Abel more. To be clear, the text doesnât say âloveâ, the first mention of that from God is Exodus 20, but God just prefers Abel to Cain because of what he gives. God has preferences for people conditional on what they kill for him, what they sacrifice for him. Just like a good father who prefers one child over another depending on how much they can lose. Them losing things pleases the good dad. (That sounds about right).
Itâs not clear what Cainâs mistake is in the text. It appears as though itâs just what heâs giving. This may have been written by some Levitical priests to foreshadow the idea that theyâd be given free food and they did NOT want people to bring them broccoli! More than likely, it was just reflective of the type of sacrifices expected at the time.
The Reaction
This bums Cain out in a big way. Heâs beside himself. Heâs such a huge fan of God, he just wants to please him. And just like any good family sitcom, thereâs an iconic scene where the dad (God) comes into the sonâs bedroom and has a heart to heart.

God says, âCheer up, Iâll like you if you do better sacrifices for me.â
This drives Cain to murder Abel.
What?!
The Problem
The problem is Cain killed Abel, but it seems like a problem of character motivation.
Cain seems to be acting on the idea that God appreciates Abel more and so to gain Godâs affection, he kills the guy God likes more. How does that make sense? This is either sloppy writing or a complete lapse in judgement from someone who is mentally unwell.
God wouldâve known Cain has psychological problems.
If you consider God being all-knowing, wise, loving, knowing that a soft answer turns away wrath, donât you think this is a moment he couldâve used his deep understanding of psychology and met Cain where he was at to say something, anything that wouldâve calmed Cain down a little?
God asks Cain where he is when heâs going to chastise him, the way he asked Adam where he was. There are ways people get around him being omniscient, but still asking questions for which he knew the answer and Iâm fine with that, but to not use his omniscience to run the scenarios to satiate Cainâs need for acceptance to save Abelâs life seems unexpected.
The Result
Cain gets cursed (if only he knew that Godâs curses are fickle and temporary)! The curse is that itâll be hard for him to do farming. Iâm not sure if itâs going to be harder than it already was from the fruit eating, but itâll be hard. This might be because God has a hard time thinking of punishments.
It also gives us a hint at Godâs moral standard: Disobeying by eating fruit is equivalent to murder. Yup, that sounds reasonable.
Cain also has to leave the three person family and go off on his own to the unpopulated world and find a wife. Maybe heâll check the animal kingdom before God borrows his rib. This is too much for Cain, he thinks all the non-existent people are going to murder him. So, God puts a mark on him so no one will kill him.
This seems like an indirect foreshadowing to the accidental murder towns to keep someone from the “avenger of bloodâ (coming soon).
Whatâs sin?
This chapter also has the first mention of sin⌠and itâs weird.
Genesis 4:7
âSin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must master it.â
Sin has desires? Sin has agency? It makes one wonder, what even is sin? Is it some external force which is coming for you, trying to deceive you? Or is it the transgression of the law?
This is where the Bible shows that itâs an evolving, changing story and âtheologyâ which isnât coherent at all. It uses poetic turns of phrase whenever the writers deem it effective or interesting, without a God orchestrating the narrative, making sure we can understand him and whatâs expected of us through it.
Anytime someone tells you what Bible is really saying, theyâre making it up and itâs an indication that thereâs no God wanting to explain something to you.
Conclusion
This story is a fun, early form of a family drama or soap opera. Itâs a violent thriller to start off a book full of violent thrillers. The Cain character is completely out of his mind and God doesnât help. Itâs not clear what anyone is supposed to learn from this except maybe âdo what youâre told, kill animals and Godâll like youâ.
There was more to this chapter, so watch the video to get those extra nuggets of questions. Thanks for reading!
Â
Full Transcript
Preview and Intro âHe loves God; heâs a huge fan. He just wants to please him. His heart was in the right placeâlike, he was really upset when he didnât pull off the right offerings that he killed his brother. Cain just had some serious mental health issues; maybe he had psychopathic tendencies.
Welcome to Joel Reads Bible. Iâm Joel, and Iâm reading the Bible. This is a series where I am reading the Bible from front to back, beginning to end, Genesis to Revelation, Alpha to OmegaâI donât know if Omega is the last one. So far, Godâs made everything. Heâs made Adam, and we learned Adamâs partnerâs name was Eve. And unfortunately, something horrible happened. Eve, with Adam right beside her, ate from this Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. They got the knowledge of good and evil, and because they did that, theyâre not going to live forever. So now weâre into Genesis chapter 4.â
Verse 1Â âAdam lay with his wife Eve, and she became pregnantâniceâand gave birth to Cain. She said, âWith the help of the Lord, I have brought forth a man.ââ
Verse 2Â âLater she gave birth to his brother Abel. Well, why donât we get the sexy detail of Adam lying with her again? You know what I mean? Now Abel kept flocks, and Cain worked the soil.â
Verse 3Â âIn the course of time, Cain brought some of the fruits of the soil as an offering to the Lord. Oh, interesting take. So we need offerings? That never happened before; this is new. God is requiringâwell, it doesnât say he requires it; maybe Cain is doing this of his own free will.â
Verse 4Â âBut Abel brought fat portions from some of the firstborn of his flock. Nice. The Lord looked with favour on Abel and his offering,â
Verse 5Â âbut on Cain and his offering he did not look with favour. So Cain was very angry, and his face was downcast.â
Verse 6 âThen the Lord said to Cain, âWhy are you angry? Why is your face downcast?â I love this because itâs like the God character is sort of speaking what the narrator just said. Itâs something that would happen comedically. I think Arrested Development has done a similar joke, but like, Cain was very angry and his face was downcast, and the Lord said to Cain, âWhy are you very angry? Why is your face downcast?â Itâs comical if you do it.â
Verse 7Â ââIf you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must master it.â At some point, we have to assume that the Lord told Cain and Abel and Adam and Eve how to do offerings, how to do sacrifices. We donât know this yetâthe narrator hasnât told usâbut he must have told them. And God loves fat animals. How do we feel about plants? Not so great, you know what I mean? And it could be that Cain wasnât bringing the most plump corn; you know what I mean? It might have been that the tomatoes were a little bit lean. He may have been saving the ones that he knows are going to be delicious and, you know, thatâs in the salad, but âthese ones are for you, God.â Godâs like, âListen, youâll be accepted if you do whatâs right.â Cain knows what that is. Sin is crouching at your door.
So this is so interesting: sin is external. This is the first mention of sin, and itâs crouching at your door. Itâs an external force; it desires to have you. The first mention of sin doesnât say sin is inside you and you are a sinful creature, etc. It says sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you. You are fighting against the external force of sin. Sin, by the way, has desires. Sin is something with, by the sounds of it, an intelligence. I accept that this could be poetic license; it might not be what sin actually is. But this is the first mention we have of sin, and Iâm sorry that Iâm harping on about it, but to understand what sin isâthis is the book for it. Sin is not a thing outside of religion, and it desires things.â
Verse 8Â âNow Cain said to his brother Abel, âLetâs go out to the field.â And while they were in the field, Cain attacked his brother Abel and killed him.
That was quick. Iâm probably going to bring this up more than once, but a lot of Christian stuffâthey love to throw around the idea of âfamily values.â This is the first family: right away, murder. I mean, Iâve got brothers; theyâre not this bad. Letâs just say that. He attacked him and he killed him, and thatâs over some jealousy. But whatâs so crazy about it is that Cain is angry and downcast because God doesnât like his gift as much. He wants God to like him; he wants to please God, but not enough to actually do the right thing. And he is going to kill his brother. What areâtheyâre inbred? That is part of the problem, I think. Theyâre inbred; theyâre not smart. They havenât thought it through. And I think part of it might be that sin was crouching at his door and it got through. It desired to have him, and it had him. He did not master that sin. They do not think; they donât reason very well. Theyâre a lot like Christians, I guess, in that senseâbut you know, thatâs a potshot. Thatâs a potshot; I donât mean that.â
Verse 9Â âThen the Lord said to Cain, âWhere is your brother Abel?â
So this is God. Heâs done this before. God is cheeky. This is part of the character of God, like, âAll right, letâs see if he lies to me.â Asking questions like thisâit feels a little bit like a test, which I always thought of as gaslighting. âBut where is your brother Abel?â Cain replied, âI donât know. Am I my brotherâs keeper?â So Cain is like, âYou know,â and he thinks heâs getting away with it. Iâm guessing weâre going to find a lot of situations where you think people would know better. You and I donât have a face-to-face relationship with GodâIâm not saying Cain didâbut thereâs some vocalizing here, like thereâs some words being spoken. Thereâs like a dialogue. And God walked in the gardenâor well, he walked in the garden, I donât know if heâs still on Earth. Probably not; probably just generally got too hot for him. But he is still like, âOkay, donât you think he would be like, âUh-oh, heâs going to know, heâs going to knowâ?ââ
Verse 10Â âThe Lord said, âWhat have you done? Listen!â
It feels like he may have slapped him. âListen!ââexclamation mark. âWhat have you done? Listen! Your brotherâs blood cries out to me from the ground.â Thatâs got to be poetic.â
Verse 11Â âNow you are under a curse.
âI cursed your mom, I cursed your dad, I cursed the serpentânow Iâm cursing you. Iâm sorry, Cain, but now you are under a curse and driven from the ground, which opened its mouth to receive your brotherâs blood from your hand.ââ
Verse 12Â ââWhen you work the ground, it will no longer yield its crops for you. You will be a restless wanderer on the earth.â
Sorry, bud. You were not even a great gardener, by the way; got to tell you, I wasnât pleased with what you were doing. So itâs no great loss to me. You can now try all you want to water the geraniums; theyâre not going to grow. Okay, buddy? Sorry. But now all youâre going to be doing is wandering. I donât know what heâs going to do for foodâprobably just get livestock, which is better anyway.â
Verse 13Â âCain said to the Lord, âMy punishment is more than I can bear.ââ
Verse 14Â ââToday you are driving me from this land, and I will be hidden from your presence.â
He loves God; heâs a huge fan. He just wants to please him. I get it; he didnât do it right, but it seems like his heart was in the right place. Like, he was really upset when he didnât pull off the right offerings and then he got so mad that he killed his brother. I have a feeling that Cain just had some serious mental health issues; he wasnât quite able to think clearly and coherently. Maybe he had psychopathic tendencies. Iâm not a psychiatrist; I donât know how to diagnose these kinds of issues that people might have. Heâs obviously obsessed with God; he wants to get it right. And then when he doesnât, he goes off the deep end. His heart breaks because heâs like, âI want to be near you; I donât want to be far away from your presence. Iâm crazy about you.â âI will be a restless wanderer on the earth, and whoever finds me will kill me.â Oh, maybe heâs just worried about his life. Maybe heâs like, âUh-oh, Iâm wandering, yeah, but also I feel like people are just going to kill me.ââ
Verse 15Â âBut the Lord said to him, âNot so; if anyone kills Cain, he will suffer vengeance seven times over.â
Whoâs he talking to? Whoâs going to find him and kill him? Thereâs one family! One of his other brothers? Like, heâs going to be so old before those other generations grow up and then theyâre able to find him and be like, âHey, I thought we were the only family. Who are you, Cain?â You know, is everyone suddenly a murderer? Like that? No, murderer is just common now. âGod, you donât get it. If they come and find me, theyâre going to murder me because Iâm not someone that tills the land anymore. Iâm just a wanderer, and you know how they always just kill wanderers.â It just seems a little bit fictional. Then the Lord put a mark on Cain so that no one who found him would kill him. So thatâs actually kind of nice; no oneâs going to kill Cain.â
Verse 16Â âSo Cain went out from the Lordâs presence and lived in the Land of Nod, east of Eden.
Which notoriously was a difficult place to sleep because at night you could see the flaming sword which was being whipped around constantly by the cherubimâwatch previous videos, youâll learn about that.â
Verse 17Â âCain lay with his wifeâwhere did she come from?âand she became pregnant and gave birth to Enoch. Cain was then building a city, and he named it after his son Enoch.â
Verse 18Â âTo Enoch was born Irad, and Irad was the father of Mehujael, and Mehujael was the father of Methushael, and Methushael was the father of Lamech.
Just so you know: where are the women coming from? Like, where are all the women that theyâre ruling over? We know that from the previous chapter, but where are they gettingâwhen the Bible doesnât mention it, itâs not important. For instance, here: itâs important what the menâs names were. Itâs so importantâevery single man. The women are not important. Where they came from and whose daughters they were is not important. Whatâs important is just those guys.â
Verse 19Â âLamech married two women, one named Adah and the other Zillah.â
Verse 20Â âAdah gave birth to Jabal. Iâm not going to be pronouncing these names correctly. He was the father of those who live in tents and raise livestock.â
Verse 21Â âHis brotherâs name was Jubal; he was the father of all who play the harp and flute. This is probably where we get the name the word âJubilee.â Thatâs neat.â
Verse 22Â âZillahâGodzillaâalso had a son, Tubal-Cain, who played the tubaâno, thatâs not trueâTubal-Cain, who forged all kinds of tools out of bronze and iron. Tubal-Cainâs sister was Naamah.â
Verse 23Â âLamech said to his wives, Adah and Zillah, âListen to me; wives of Lamech, hear my words. I have killed a man for wounding me.â
Murder is more common. But I mean, this is Lamech, by the wayâgreat-great-great-great-great-great-grandson of Cain. So itâs in the bloodline. âI have killed a man for wounding me, a young man for injuring me.ââ
Verse 24Â ââIf Cain is avenged seven times, then Lamech seventy-seven times.â
Heâs proclaiming his own Mark of Cain, if you will. You know, you kill Cain, youâre going to get it; you kill Lamech, 77 times. Heâs just kind of making that up. I do want to bring up that Lamech has two wives. That seems fine; thereâs no problem with that. I donât know where all these women are coming from; they were probably his sisters. But he got two of them. And it could have also been that he was the only guy. You know, it didnât say that like Methushael was the father of Lamech and Tobias. It was just Lamech, and he may have been the father of Adah and Zillahâor maybe Zillah was his mom too, who knows? But at that point, there could be a little bit more diversity because it could have been like one of them could be the granddaughter of Enochâs other son. I think it is fun that thereâs polygamy here and that there doesnât seem to be a problem with it. Is it wrong? Are we going to learn that itâs wrong, or is this great? Is this just something we can do?â
Verse 25Â âAdam lay with his wife again, and she became pregnant and gave birth to a son and named him Seth, saying, âGod has granted me another child in place of Abel, since Cain killed him.ââ
Verse 26Â âSeth also had a sonâwith whom we will not knowâand named him Enosh. Nice. At that time men began to call on the name of the Lord.
Whatâs that supposed to mean? I mean, they were doing offerings already, but now they just started calling on them anyway.â
Closing Thoughts âThatâs chapter 4, so who knows whatâs going to happen in chapter 5. Iâm excited to find out. If youâre excited to find out too, please subscribe. If you have a comment on this book or if you notice something that I read that I didnât pick up on and I didnât mention, please leave it in the comments and enlighten everybody thatâs watching. Because thatâs part of the journey here is that weâre really reading the Bibleâweâre not cherry-picking, Iâm not telling you what it says, weâre not listening to some person whoâs going to claim that they know what this interpretation means. Weâre just taking the words at face value. And I think youâre able to do that because itâs the infallible word of God, which is inspired and revelatory. So letâs continue. Iâll be back for chapter 5, of course. Bless you.â
Hey, Joel. You’re onto something when you talked about Abel giving the firstborn of his flock. Both Cain and Abel are giving their livelihood as a sacrifice. There’s a contrast between what the two gave for sure. By comparison, Cain gave *some* of his crops, implying that it wasn’t anything out of the ordinary. Hebrews 11:4 speaks to this, saying “By faith Abel brought God a better offering than Cain did. By faith he was commended as righteous, when God spoke well of his offerings. And by faith Abel still speaks, even though he is dead”. Consistently in scripture, God examines our hearts and motivation. In this case Cain’s heart was in a place that was lacking.
More importantly, though, I think that looking at passages in this way reveals an issue with the premise of the examination in the first place. The overarching question between this and other breakdowns is “if God is good, then why did He do ______?”. There’s a really big problem with judging the actions of God as being bad or good. No matter what, if God exists, then He would be the standard of good and evil. Essentially, if we were to disagree with something He did, then we’d already be deemed incorrect by definition. What you’re really saying is that from your own limited perspective, you can’t understand why God would do something like that. Well of course, if we as finite beings could 100% understand an infinite God, then that wouldn’t be God at all. In fact, if there is no God, then morality is subjective and it would be impossible to deem anything as good or bad since there’s no absolute foundation. It’s a fallacy, in my opinion, to say that God wouldn’t exist or that the Bible is false, just because we disagree with the state of things.
What we really should focus on in terms of disproving the Bible is evidence surrounding the gospel and resurrection itself. If that part of the Bible is trustworthy, it legitimizes everything that came before, including this particular story. Reading a passage and
The reimagining of Hebrews is neat, but theyâre just adding to the story. Obviously God preferred Cainâs offering, but it could be that he loves the smell of burning flesh, which is reflected in the burnt offerings he commands in the Torah. The Cain/abel story is likely just a foreshadowing to that. I mean, he wanted the first fruits before the whole firstborn thing tho the firstborn thing is the explanation for the dedication of the firstborns. Itâs a bit of an anachronism.
I think my main problems with this story is in the narrative and poor character motivation. But yes, the God character certainly doesnât know how people will react to his blunt communication. He shouldâve supported Cainâs failing mental health. But thatâs me taking this rudimentary folk tale seriously.